What is the ZIP code for Metuchen, NJ?

The ZIP code for Metuchen, NJ is 08840. This ZIP code covers the Borough of Metuchen and small portions of the surrounding Edison Township area in Middlesex County.

What county is Metuchen, NJ in?

Metuchen is located in Middlesex County, New Jersey. It is a borough completely surrounded by Edison Township, making it one of New Jersey's so-called 'doughnut towns.'

What school district serves Metuchen, NJ?

Metuchen is served by the Metuchen Borough School District, which operates four schools: Mildred B. Moss Elementary (Pre-K–K), Campbell Elementary (Grades 1–4), Edgar Middle School (Grades 5–8), and Metuchen High School (Grades 9–12). Private school options include St. Joseph High School and Saint Francis Cathedral School.

What types of homes are available in Metuchen, NJ?

Metuchen's housing stock is primarily composed of single-family homes, many of which were built in the 1940s and 1950s. Buyers will find colonials, Cape Cods, and ranches throughout the borough. Multi-family properties and condominiums are also available, particularly near the downtown and train station area.

Is Metuchen, NJ a good place to live?

Metuchen is widely considered one of New Jersey's most desirable small boroughs. In April 2024, Money Magazine named Metuchen the best place to live in New Jersey and one of the best in the country. Known as the 'Brainy Boro,' it offers a walkable downtown, direct train service to New York Penn Station, top-rated public schools, and a strong sense of community.

How far is Metuchen, NJ from New York City?

Metuchen is approximately 25 miles southwest of Midtown Manhattan. By car via the New Jersey Turnpike or Route 1, the trip typically takes 35–50 minutes depending on traffic. NJ Transit's Northeast Corridor Line provides direct rail service from Metuchen Station to New York Penn Station, with a typical train ride of approximately 45–55 minutes.

What are property taxes like in Metuchen, NJ?

Property taxes in Metuchen reflect Middlesex County and New Jersey rates. Median real estate taxes paid on homes with mortgages were approximately $9,603 annually as of 2023. NJ homeowners may qualify for tax relief programs including the ANCHOR Benefit, Senior Freeze (PTR), the $250 Senior/Veteran Deduction, and the StayNJ program. Always verify current program details with the NJ Division of Taxation at njtaxation.org.

What parks and recreation are in Metuchen, NJ?

Metuchen offers several parks and recreational areas. Centennial Park is the borough's largest at 13 acres, featuring Beacon Hill — the highest point in the borough at 169 feet — located off Grove Avenue. Tommy's Pond is a 1.8-acre site used for an annual fishing derby. The Middlesex Greenway is a 3.5-mile paved trail connecting Metuchen to Woodbridge Township and serving as part of the larger East Coast Greenway. The Dismal Swamp is a natural preserve area near the borough.

What towns border Metuchen, NJ?

Metuchen is unique in that it is completely surrounded by Edison Township on all sides, making it one of New Jersey's 'doughnut towns.' Edison is the sole bordering municipality. Nearby communities accessible via Route 27, Route 1, and I-287 include Woodbridge, South Plainfield, Piscataway, and New Brunswick.

Does Hallmark Realtors serve Metuchen, NJ?

Yes. Hallmark Realtors has been serving Metuchen and Middlesex County for over 40 years. As a family-owned, independent brokerage established in 1984, Hallmark brings deep local knowledge to every Metuchen transaction — whether you are buying, selling, or exploring your options. Contact us today for a free consultation.

Metuchen NJ Homes for Sale | Real Estate in Metuchen Borough 08840

About the Community

Life in Metuchen — New Jersey's "Brainy Boro"

Metuchen is a vibrant, close-knit borough in Middlesex County with a well-earned reputation as one of Central New Jersey's most desirable places to call home. In April 2024, Money Magazine named Metuchen the best place to live in New Jersey — and one of the best in the entire country. The recognition reflects what residents have long known: Metuchen balances small-town charm with exceptional amenities, outstanding schools, and unmatched commuter access.

Known affectionately as the "Brainy Boro," Metuchen has attracted artists, academics, and professionals since the late 19th century. The borough's compact 2.85-square-mile footprint is served by a single ZIP code (08840) and is uniquely surrounded on all sides by Edison Township — one of New Jersey's rare "doughnut towns." This geographic distinction gives Metuchen a distinct identity while benefiting from the infrastructure and services of a large surrounding municipality.

The downtown along Main Street and surrounding blocks offers independent dining, boutique retail, and community gathering spaces that national portals simply cannot capture in a listing description. The Middlesex Greenway, a 3.5-mile multi-use trail, connects the borough directly to Woodbridge Township while serving as part of the larger East Coast Greenway network. Centennial Park — Metuchen's largest green space at 13 acres — anchors recreational life near the center of town.

For buyers, Metuchen's housing stock skews toward single-family homes built primarily in the 1940s and 1950s, including classic colonials, Cape Cods, and ranches on established tree-lined streets. Demand consistently outpaces supply, making early representation by an experienced local agent essential. Hallmark Realtors has guided buyers and sellers through Metuchen's market for more than four decades.

Metuchen, NJ Homes for Sale

Homes for Sale in Metuchen, NJ

Property Search Results

Life in Metuchen — New Jersey's "Brainy Boro"

What Makes Metuchen Special

Homes for Sale in Metuchen, NJ

Property Search Results

Get Instant Alerts on New Listings

Sign Up for Instant Updates Now

Login to Your Account

Sign up to Save this Listing

Life in Metuchen — New Jersey's "Brainy Boro"

What Makes Metuchen Special

Login to My Homefinder

We have detected that you have cookies disabled.